Senior Director, Total Rewards
At Credit Acceptance, we are building on the foundation of a successful business while investing in the future through technology, data, AI, and continuous improvement. As we continue to evolve, our Team Members play an active role in improving experiences, driving meaningful change, and shaping the future of our business. We foster an environment where people are empowered to contribute ideas, develop their careers, make an impact, and help lead our continued transformation.
Our Enterprise teams provide the expertise, insights, and partnership that help our business and people succeed. Team Members collaborate across the organization to solve challenges, support informed decision-making, and enable the strategies and initiatives that move our business forward. We value curiosity, continuous learning, and diverse perspectives from people who are passionate about making a meaningful impact on our customers, Team Members, and business.
This role carries a mandate to rethink Total Rewards from first principles: start with the outcomes we want, then design purpose-built solutions rather than defaulting to inherited programs, processes, and systems.
You will bring deep compensation expertise, including the chance to reexamine executive compensation, merit and incentive programs, and equity plans, and you will lead benefits and payroll, keeping them accurate, compliant, and reliable through the change. Success means a Total Rewards capability that makes better decisions possible, delivers a simpler and more valuable experience, and keeps improving.
Outcomes and Activities:
Shape the Strategy
- Define a Total Rewards philosophy and strategy tied to our business priorities and talent needs, with clear principles for pay competitiveness, internal equity, and performance differentiation.
- Lead the design of executive compensation, base pay, merit, short- and long-term incentives, and equity programs, rewarding the behaviors we want and anticipating unintended consequences.
- Advise senior executives on complex compensation decisions, including analysis and recommendations for the Board’s Compensation Committee.
Design and Deploy Purpose-Built Solutions
- Evaluate every program, policy, process, vendor, and system, and decide what to preserve, improve, redesign, or discontinue.
- Combine policy, process, technology, data, and human expertise to build purpose-built solutions, applying automation and AI and removing unnecessary policies, approvals, and complexity.
- Set hypotheses and measures of success, deliver in increments, and build resilient systems that reduce manual dependencies and strengthen controls.
Deliver Operational Excellence and Sound Governance
- Lead compensation, benefits, payroll, and equity administration with accuracy, timeliness, security, and strong controls, including backup coverage and continuity planning.
- Ensure compliance with federal, state, and local requirements, including wage and hour, payroll tax, ERISA, ACA, and securities disclosure, in partnership with Legal, Finance, and Internal Audit, and support Compensation Committee materials.
- Own benefits design and sustainability, along with Total Rewards budgets, vendors, and technology investments.
Build Organizational Capability and Strong Partnerships
- Build and lead a high-performing Total Rewards team with deep expertise in each discipline, strong functional leaders, and clear accountability.
- Decide what to build internally and what to source externally, and foster curiosity, constructive challenge, and experimentation.
- Partner with HR, Finance, Legal, Technology, and business leaders, translating complex technical, financial, and regulatory issues into clear choices for executives.
Competencies
- Thinks from First Principles: Questions why existing standards, policies, and processes work the way they do, and breaks problems down to root causes before proposing solutions. Uses data and the needs of the customer and the business to form hypotheses, tests them quickly, and iterates. Prioritizes and advocates for the improvements that contribute most to intrinsic value.
- Makes Quality Decisions: Applies high judgment when making decisions, balancing risks, rewards, and speed, even when information is incomplete or the path is unclear. Understands the needs of those impacted, involves the right people early and often, and iterates as new information emerges.
- Works at the Frontier: Adopts the most capable emerging tools and methods early, including AI today, and uses them to redesign how work gets done, not just to make existing work faster or more accurate. Experiments regularly, applies sound judgment on when to trust and verify results, and shares what works so others can adopt it. Works within Company data and security guidelines and understands how changes to tools, platforms, and methods affect the enterprise and its technical ecosystem.
- Influences Through Evidence and Conviction: Frames complex issues as clear choices with a recommendation, and brings the evidence and judgment to stand behind it. Builds trust with senior leaders and boards, challenges them respectfully when the data points elsewhere, and keeps people aligned through decisions that are not popular.
- Builds Capability Through Others: Sets a clear outcome and a single owner for every piece of work, then hires, develops, and holds a high bar for the people who can own it. Delegates real decisions, builds depth so no result depends on one person, and removes obstacles. Creates an environment of trust, candor, and diverse perspectives where the team produces more together than any individual could, and measures success by what the team delivers and what its members become.
Minimum Qualifications
- Bachelor’s degree from an accredited institution in an analytical or technical field.
- 10+ years of progressive Total Rewards experience, with deep expertise in compensation strategy, design, and governance.
- Direct experience designing executive compensation, annual incentive and merit programs, and long-term incentive or equity programs, including public company governance.
- Demonstrated success redesigning compensation strategy, structures, and programs, and leading complex change such as policy simplification or technology modernization, with measurable results.
- Proven success building and leading teams of functional specialists, including developing leaders, with enough knowledge of benefits and payroll to lead and oversee them.
- Strong financial, analytical, and regulatory judgment, the ability to use data, technology, and structured problem-solving to improve decisions and simplify operations, and the executive presence to present recommendations to CEOs, CFOs, CHROs, and board committees.
Preferred Qualifications
- Relevant professional certifications, such as CCP, CEBS, or CPP.
- Experience in financial services, consumer lending, or another regulated industry.
- Experience leading technology-enabled transformation, such as systems modernization, vendor changes, or operating model redesign.
- Familiarity with HR and payroll platforms, including Workday and ADP.
- Experience presenting to a board compensation committee.
- Experience designing rewards and incentives that balance growth, profitability, risk, and long-term enterprise value.
Targeted Compensation: $262,800 - $306,600 base salary + annual bonus plan
Benefits
- Excellent benefits package that includes 401(K) match, adoption assistance, parental leave, tuition reimbursement, comprehensive medical/ dental/vision and many nonstandard benefits that make us a Great Place to Work
Our Company Values:
To be successful in this role, Team Members need to be:
- Positive by maintaining resiliency and focusing on solutions
- Respectful by collaborating and actively listening
- Insightful by cultivating innovation, accumulating business and role specific knowledge, demonstrating self-awareness and making quality decisions
- Direct by effectively communicating and conveying courage
- Earnest by taking accountability, applying feedback and effectively planning and priority setting
Expectations:
- Remain compliant with our policies processes and legal guidelines
- All other duties as assigned
- Attendance as required by department
Advice!
We understand that your career search may look different than others. Our hiring team wants to make sure that this would be a fit not just for us, but for you long term. If you are actively looking or starting to explore new opportunities, send us your application!
P.S.
We have great details around our stats, success, history and more. We’re proud of our culture and are happy to share why – let’s talk!
Required degrees must have been earned at institutions of Higher Education which are accredited by the Council for Higher Education Accreditation or equivalent.
Credit Acceptance is dedicated to providing an inclusive environment for all. We are proud to be an Equal Opportunity Employer and value a culturally diverse workforce. We believe in ensuring all team members demonstrate mutual respect for one another. All qualified applicants will receive consideration for employment without regard to protected characteristics like age, race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, veteran or disability status.
California Residents: Please click here for the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) notice regarding the personal information Credit Acceptance may collect from you.
Play the video below to learn more about our Company culture.
Required Skills
Required Languages
🇬🇧 English